Cigar Reviews

Ratings are the average based on a blind tasting of each cigar by our expert panel of ten cigar connoisseurs, who together possess more than 100 years of cigar smoking experience.

90%C&S Rating

ATABEY

Tasting Notes: The ATABEY cigar leaves have many origins, they are from Caribbean and Central America countries. Medium in strength, this is a smooth...
88%C&S Rating

FABLE CIGAR: FOURTH PRIME

Tasting Notes: Dominated by sweeter elements, the flavor profile is highlighted by a core of chocolate, sweet spices and peppers with hints of coffee...
94%C&S Rating

AGING ROOM: QUATTRO F55M

Tasting Notes: A mild to medium plus cigar with immaculate construction. Creamy notes of cedar and earth throughout the smoke with a slightly peppery...
88%C&S Rating

CALDWELL: ALL OUT KINGS

Tasting Notes: The All Out Kings is a masterful collaboration between Drew Estate and Caldwell Cigar Co. A medium to full-bodied smoke with flavors o...
90%C&S Rating

SINDICATO: AFFINITY

Tasting Notes: Affinity is a medium-bodied cigar with flawless Connecticut seed wrapper grown in Ecuador. This creamy smoke is masterfully blended wi...
89%C&S Rating

LA AURORA: BLACK LION

Tasting Notes: Medium to full bodied smoke with a slow even burn and very rich with flavor. This creamy cigar includes notes of citrus, cocoa, cedar,...
91%C&S Rating

KRISTOFF: SAN ANDRES

Tasting Notes: The Kristoff San Andrés is an extremely rich medium-full bodied cigar with pronounced notes of spice, a hint of black pepper, sweet mi...
91%C&S Rating

AJ FERNANDEZ ENCLAVE HABANO

Tasting Notes: The rich Habano Rosado wrapper from Ecuador compliments a decadent Cameroon binder greeting the smoker with notes of pepper, spice, ce...
91%C&S Rating

AGING ROOM PELO DE ORO

Tasting Notes: Pelo de Oro tobacco is well known for its distinctive flavor and body. Medium to full-bodied smoke loaded with flavors of spice, oak, ...