Ratings are the average based on a blind tasting of each cigar by our expert panel of ten cigar connoisseurs, who together possess more than 100 years of cigar smoking experience.
Alec Bradley: Gatekeeper
Robusto 5 x 50 Wrapper: Ecuadorian [...]
Arturo Fuente: Opus x Angel's Share
5.20 x 50 Robusto Wrapper: Dominican [...]
Daniel Marshall Cigars: Daniel X Carlito XXXVIII Anniversary Cigar Limited Edition 2020
Torpedo 6 3/8 x 52 Wrapper: [...]
MADAM PATTIRINI GIN
A tasty blend of juniper, Sicilian lemon, Nigerian ginger, coriander, [...]
JC NEWMAN DIAMOND CROWN MAXIMUS DOUBLE ROBUSTO #6
Tasting Notes: Full-bodied yet smooth; sweet with mocha, hint of [...]
HIRAM & SOLOMON CIGARS TRAVELING MAN
Tasting Notes: Medium bodied blend with a creamy texture. Delightful [...]
HIRAM & SOLOMON CIGARS SHRINER
Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied blend with a smooth and perfect construction. [...]
DUNBARTON TOBACCO & TRUST MUESTRA DE SAKA NACATAMALE
Tasting Notes: A line of unique blends and vitolas made [...]
DUNBARTON TOBACCO & TRUST: LAS DIAS DOUBLE WIDE BELICOSO
Tasting Notes: This Nicaraguan Puro features a sun-grown capa with [...]
DUNBARTON TOBACCO & TRUST: SOBREMESA ELEGANTE EN CEDROS
Tasting Notes: A medium- to full-bodied cigar that begins with [...]
DREW ESTATE & CALDWELL ALL OUT KINGS
Tasting Notes: Medium- to full-bodied cigar offering a complex profile [...]
DAVIDOFF WINSTON CHURCHILL – THE LATE HOUR
Tasting Notes: This full-bodied blend manifests itself in many beautiful, [...]
DAVIDOFF LIMITED EDITION YEAR OF THE DOG
Tasting Notes: Sweet flavors at the start, semi-sweet chocolate with [...]
CALDWELL: THE LAST TSAR
Tasting Notes: Medium in body, creamy and smooth. Very rich. [...]
BOUTIQUE BLENDS AGING ROOM BIN NO. 1 B
Tasting Notes: Full-bodied, full of hickory and nougat notes, complemented [...]
BLANCO NINE
Tasting Notes: A full flavor cigar with notes of wood [...]
ARTURO FUENTE DON CARLOS LANCERO
Tasting Notes: Medium-to-medium plus creamy smoke. Initial flavors of wood [...]
ALTADIS U.S.A. THE BANKER BY H. UPMANN
Tasting Notes: Rich, full-flavored and spicy, with robust body and [...]
ALTADIS U.S.A. TRINIDAD SANTIAGO
Tasting Notes: Medium- to full-bodied cigar that is full of [...]
AJ FERNANDEZ ENCLAVE BROADLEAF TORO
Tasting Notes: This bold blend is accentuated by an earthy, [...]
AJ FERNANDEZ SAN LOTANO REQUIEM HABANO TORO
Tasting Notes: The San Lotano Habano by AJ Fernandez is [...]
THE BALVENIE: 14 YEAR-OLD
A unique single malt featuring rum cask finishing. Created by maturing [...]
CATTLE BARON CIGARS: COWBOY
Tasting Notes: This cigar has a rich, natural, and aromatic [...]
CALDWELL: THE LAST TSAR
Tasting Notes: Medium in body, creamy and smooth. Very rich. [...]
“TOP 20 CIGARS OF 2017 #1” JC NEWMAN: DIAMOND CROWN JULIUS CAESER
Tasting Notes: Medium-Full Strength smoke. Decadent flavors include hints [...]
“TOP 20 CIGARS OF 2017 #2” PADRÓN FAMILY: RESERVE 50 YEARS
Tasting Notes: Medium to full-bodied; notes of chocolate, coffee, earth [...]